April 19, 2017 - Please click to download the PDF version of the Litigation Wrap: First Quarter 2017.
$7.3B Settlement Approved
Hughes Hubbard helped lead the European affiliates of Nortel Networks to a final resolution of their insolvency proceedings when judges in Delaware and Canada signed off on a settlement ending an eight-year international dispute over how to divide the $7.3 billion raised from the company's liquidation. Derek Adler, Bill Maguire and Neil Oxford led the team which included Gabrielle Glemann.
First of Their Kind BIT Decisions
A team led by John Townsend, Marc-Olivier Langlois and Jim Boykin won the first decisions to find a bilateral investment treaty (BIT) applicable to territory regarded as illegally occupied by the international community. On Feb. 24, a Permanent Court of Arbitration tribunal decided to hear claims regarding expropriations in Crimea against the Russian Federation by Aeroport Belbek and its owner Igor Valerievich Kolomoisky, and, in a separate case, by PrivatBank, Ukraine's largest bank. On March 20, a second tribunal decided to hear additional claims against the Russian Federation by the owners of parcels of Crimean real estate that were similarly expropriated.
Firm Wins Tax Fraud Suit
Hughes Hubbard earned a big win for Rabobank on Jan. 18, when a Nevada state court judge tossed an action seeking to hold the Dutch financial services provider liable for a failed tax shelter it had financed. Chris Paparella argued the motion and led the team, which included Sarah Cave.
SEC Settlement for Wipro
On Dec. 22, HHR helped India-based Wipro Ltd. resolve a six-year investigation by the SEC relating to its foreign exchange accounting practices. The outcome was favorable, avoiding protracted litigation and imposing a fine of only $5 million. Kevin Abikoff and Benjamin Britz led the team, which included Roel Campos, Terence Healy, and Bill Stein.
Two Wins for TicoFrut
On Jan. 30, Ruben Diaz, Nick Swerdloff, and Aviva Wernick won a victory in Federal court in the Southern District of Florida for the Pellas Group's TicoFrut when a judge denied Del Monte's request to garnish TicoFrut's payments to a pineapple grower to satisfy a $32 million arbitral award against the grower. On March 7, HHR won a second victory when the judge denied Del Monte's motion for a preliminary injunction prohibiting TicoFrut from buying pineapples from the same grower.
Renewed Lumber Trade War
In a renewed trade war with the U.S. over Canadian exports of softwood lumber, Hughes Hubbard is serving as legal counsel to the government of Canada and heading up a multi-firm team representing all the Canadian provinces and industry associations. The last round of lumber cases (2001-2006) ended with a negotiated agreement and a complete victory for Canada with $5 billion in illegally collected duties being returned to Canadian producers. Joanne Osendarp leads the HHR team which includes Eric Parnes, Matt Nicely, Lynn Kamarck and Alan Kashdan.
Lehman Distribution Approved
On March 23, the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York approved the Trustee's motion to pay another $228 million to unsecured general creditors of the brokerage, bringing their total recovery to approximately $9 billion. "The potential to bring unsecured general creditor recovery to 39 percent exceeds all expectations at the outset of this liquidation," said Trustee Jim Giddens, in a statement.
Class Action Settlement with NY
On Feb. 27, HHR and the Legal Aid Society announced the favorable settlement, subject to court approval, of their class action lawsuit attacking inadequate housing assistance for poor families. The settlement will substantially increase the monthly rent subsidies available for low income families in New York City, expand the city's public rental assistance program, and help thousands of families avoid eviction and homelessness. Ted Mayer and Fara Tabatabai led HHR's efforts in this matter.
Acquittal at Trial in Assault Case
Will Coronato won an acquittal of assault and restraining order violation charges against a pro bono client. On March 2, a New Jersey Superior Court Judge found our client not guilty of all charges and dismissed the complaint after a bench trial, stating that the accuser's version of events did not add up.